Saturday, March 1, 2008

The XO Laptop And Sustainable Design Part 1

One of the talks I heard at the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) annual meeting in Boston last week was Nicholas Negroponte presenting the current state of the One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) project. OLPC is one of those paradigm-shifting ideas that seeks to upend our expectations of what can and can’t be done, in this case with regards to the education and connectivity of children in the developing world. I was fairly skeptical of the OLPC program at first, but Negroponte’s talk challenged my assumptions about the possibility of using Internet age technology in poor countries. After coming back from AAAS I was able to borrow one of the laptops (called the “XO”) from a friend and stayed up half the night enthusiastically tooling around its OS and various applications. My impression of the XO was a rugged, durable tool, with real potential to connect children to each other and to a wider world. However, I don’t think I’m going to convince anyone of that with a blog post, I think you have to see a demonstration of the operating system in order to appreciate what it has the potential to accomplish.

More information on that aspect of the XO and “Sugar” operating system is available at www.laptop.org (the OLPC website), or by watching some of Nicholas Negroponte’s presentations on Youtube.

However, the most common objection that I’ve heard from folks familiar with the concept has to do with what might be called the “waste stream” of the product. There is a real concern from folks sympathetic to the OLPC ideals that providing electronics to millions of children worldwide could have unintended consequences with regards to pollution, trash, etc. This is well worth considering. In this post I’d like to briefly review a few ideas relating to the “sustainability” of the XO and then in a follow-up (Part 2) comment on some properties of the XO as examples of sustainable design in electronics.

The first idea I’d like to introduce is a self-critical one: our concern about electronic waste doesn’t extend to refusing to buy ourselves laptops. Not that it should, in my opinion laptops make life substantively better using metrics of community, creativity, and connectivity. Accepting that assumption, the issue then shifts from “whither electronics” to “sustainable electronics.” That then becomes the question I’d like to consider in Part 2, how do we evaluate the XO, and laptops in general, according to their sustainability as physical objects? At this point, it may be useful to mention that “sustainability” can refer to things like energy use as well as more traditional measures of pollution (i.e. cadmium or mercury entering the environment from the disposal of batteries).

However, before moving into that discussion in earnest, I’d like to further explore our instinctive concern about e-waste in the developing world. I suspect, although I would suggest it gently, that some of our concern regarding OLPC and sustainability is less about harm done to the environment and more about our concern over inducting children from poor countries into modern, post-industrial society. That concern is real, and it is laudable, but we need to make sure we’re honest about what we’re discussing. Concerns about e-waste or energy use can be evaluated according to objective metrics of wattage, heavy metal pollution, etc. and that’s what I’m interested in following up on in Part 2. Concerns about the costs, benefits, positives, and negatives of post-industrial society are different questions, not to be placed off limits, but to be discussed clearly for what they are and not mixed into concerns over the sustainability of the XO as a physical object.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

I truly believe that we have reached the point where technology has become one with our lives, and I am fairly certain that we have passed the point of no return in our relationship with technology.

I don't mean this in a bad way, of course! Ethical concerns aside... I just hope that as the price of memory decreases, the possibility of copying our memories onto a digital medium becomes a true reality. It's one of the things I really wish I could encounter in my lifetime.

(Posted from Nintendo DS running [url=http://www.gather.com/viewArticle.action?articleId=281474978023679]R4i[/url] N3T 2)

Anonymous said...

Creating muscle [B][URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com]p90x workout[/URL][/B] through getting supplement is never enough and does not entirely ensure an enviable effect. [B]does p90x work[/B] should place in mind the fact that system isn't made through the supplements, but rather they are only directed to support you within your mission of creating muscles. The most essential aspect would definitely be your diet and discipline even though possessing your weight education. [B][URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com]p90x workout[/URL][/B] A good and balanced eating plan can also be critical. Enable time to take its course and don't do issues in haste. As lengthy as [B][URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com/insanity-workout-dvds.html]insanity reviews[/URL][/B] exert an effort to change your not so pleasing practices then be confident because you might undoubtedly have the ability to actualize what you've been wishing - a leaner and masculine physique.

[URL=http://www.fitnessworkoutclub.com][IMG]http://www.beachbody.com/images/en_US/products/programs/insanity/ins_sell_chrisb_b.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

Anonymous said...

[B][URL=http://www.thomassabosale.de]Thomas Sabo charms[/URL][/B] [B]Thomas Sabo schmuck[/B] [U]Thomas Sabo[/U] [B]mtb masai[/B] [U]mbt[/U] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]masai schuhe[/URL][/B]

[B]Thomas Sabo schmuck[/B] [B][URL=http://www.thomassabosale.de]Thomas Sabo onlineshop[/URL][/B] [U]Thomas Sabo charms[/U] abercrombie and fitch [B]masai[/B] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]mbt[/URL][/B] [U]masai footwear[/U] vibram [B]Thomas Sabo schmuck[/B] [B][URL=http://www.salethomassabo.com]Thomas Sabo charms[/URL][/B] [U]Thomas Sabo onlineshop[/U] masai schuhe [B]vibram fivefingers[/B] [B][URL=http://www.vibramfivefingersshop.de]vibram[/URL][/B] [U]vibram fivefingers[/U] Thomas Sabo schmuck [B]abercrombie[/B] [B][URL=http://www.abercrombieonsale.de]abercormbie & fitch[/URL][/B] [U]abercrombie[/U]

[B]abercormbie fitch[/B] [U]abercrombie[/U] [B][URL=http://www.abercrombieonsale.de]abercrombie[/URL][/B] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]mtb schuhe masai[/URL][/B] [B]swiss masai[/B] [U]masai[/U] [B][URL=http://www.thomassabosale.de]Thomas Sabo[/URL][/B] [B]Thomas Sabo[/B] [U]Thomas Sabo[/U] [B]masai schuhe[/B] [U]masai footwear[/U] [B][URL=http://www.mbtschuheoutlet.de]masai barefoot[/URL][/B]

Anonymous said...

Jewelry is women's best friend. It is surely a [B][URL=http://www.tiffanysfree.com]tiffany charms[/URL][/B] long lasting gift to your loved ones and enhances ones beauty [U]tiffany company jewelry[/U] with its attention getting charm. So, while buying such beautiful jewelry for [B]best website to buy discounted tiffany jewelry[/B] your precious ones, you need to make [B]tiffany company jewelry[/B] sure that you get them from trust worthy places. Pandora bracelets, Links of London, Tiffany jewelry [U][B]best website to buy discounted tiffany jewelry[/U][/B] offer you top edge designs and high quality jewelry at affordable prices. They are known for their [U][B]cheap tiffany and co jewelry[/U][/B] elegant yet bright designs that could match any occasion. Jewelry these brands offer has a specific [B][URL=http://www.etiffanystore.com]tiffany engagement rings[/URL][/B] meaning that expresses many feelings.

Silver bangles and bracelets of Tiffany jewelry [B][URL=http://www.etiffanystore.com]tiffany bracelets[/URL][/B] are known for their delicate knots and symbols which express unity and harmony. Their heart shaped lockets which express love make [U][B]best website to buy discounted tiffany jewelry[/U][/B] their partner feels that they are precious [B]authentic tiffany jewelry monthly promotion[/B] and wonderful.

These jewelries are quite famous [B]tiffany jewelry store[/B] among couples who say that these unique and simple [U]authentic tiffany jewelry monthly promotion[/U] designs of Tiffany jewelry are long-lasting and incomparable. Some [U][B]buyers of tiffany jewelry sets[/U][/B] designs in Tiffany's jewelry date back to decades ago, which make them [B][URL=http://www.tiffanysfree.com]tiffany[/URL][/B] a perfect gift as a heirloom, so that it could be passed from one generation to another, this explains the timeless beauty [U]tiffany company jewelry[/U] of the jewelry and still be in fashion even after many generations

Pandora bracelets are exquisite and its [U][B]authentic tiffany jewelry monthly promotion[/U][/B] lovely charm casts a spell on every one who sees it. It is irresistible to stop thinking about [B]replica tiffany jewelry[/B] the wonderful piece of art once you have seen it. Jewelry of the line of Pandora bracelets are designed with [U]fake tiffany jewelry[/U] great care keeping in mind of tastes of millions of people, not to mention about [U][B]tiffany jewelry boxes[/U][/B] the current fashion too. They would make a perfect choice for [U]baltimore tiffany jewelry[/U] all those modern women to whom [U][B]baltimore tiffany jewelry[/U][/B] fashion is everything.

Anonymous said...

Shoes specially made for losing weight are available today and [B][URL=http://www.mbtplus.com/]footwear etc[/URL][/B] can be quite effective. These shoes have been out for a while and some companies have risen to the top [B]mbt shoes sale[/B] demonstrated that they can provide a quality product to consumers. One [U]mbt shoes cheap[/U] such type of these shoes is the MBT Shoe made by a company called Swiss Masai. In case you [U][B]mbt shoes sale[/U][/B] did not MBT stands for Masai Barefoot Technology. In this write up we want to take a [U]footwear etc[/U] closer look at these special shoes.

The development and idea behind the MBT shoe design is quite [U][B]mbt sneakers[/U][/B] interesting. What the shoe attempts to do is structure the shape of the shoe so [U]MBT shoes[/U] that it simulates walking on sand. Specifically, the they want to attempt to make it as if you are walking [U]MBT[/U] along the natural sand environment of the Masai in Kenya. Sports trainers have known for quite a while now [U]mbt shoes sale[/U] that working out on dry sand is a great way to get in excellent cardiovascular condition. As you [U]mbt sandals[/U] walk on sand it creates an uneven surface on your feet and it forces you to shift your center of gravity to [U]mbt shoes sale[/U] an unnatural position. Your body compensates for this by using several different [B]mbt discount shoes[/B] muscle groups in your feet, calves, thighs, and torso that you would not use wearing typical shoes. This is the ideas [U]MBT[/U] behind the MBT weight loss shoes and it does seem to [B][URL=http://www.mbtplus.com/]mbt shoes sale[/URL][/B] work for some people.

More specifically, MBT makes several positive claims [U]mbt shoes best prices[/U] and benefits from wearing their shoes. They will take muscle groups [U][B]mbt shoes sale[/U][/B] not normally used in walking and make them active. The shoes will give you a better posture, and a more effective [U][B]MBT shoes[/U][/B] gait when walking with or without the shoes. It can [B]mbt shoes review[/B] potentially help you with problems you may have with your back, hips, legs, and feet. The [U][B]mbt discount shoes[/U][/B] shoes can help you recover from injuries to your [B]footwear etc[/B] tendons, joints, ligaments, or muscles. The shoes are also designed to alleviate tension and stress [U]mbt shoes sale[/U] on your lower joints.


Overall owners of the MBT shoe really like the results. [B]mbt shoes review[/B] It is typical that if you walk for three or four miles at a time for several times [U][B]mbt shoes clearance[/U][/B] per week you will experience some weight loss. Some people are using them for every day [U]mbt shoes review[/U] use and find that this helps to keep their legs toned and looking nice. These are just walking [U][B]mbt discount shoes[/U][/B] shoes you really do not want to use them for running. It is recommended that you go to a store and try them on, as you [B]MBT[/B] want to make sure the heel is snug and fits correctly. If the shoes fit correctly they should feel snug and it should [B]MBT shoes[/B] feel as though you are walking on stilts when you walk in [U]mbt shoes cheap[/U] them.

Anonymous said...

If you're interested in improving your health, it [B][URL=http://www.mbtplus.com/]mbt sneakers[/URL][/B] can be beneficial to start from the ground up. Let's talk about your footwear. How does [B]MBT[/B] yours rank? Some so-called fitness shoes merely look great, but don't really provide [B]mbt shoes best prices[/B] any actual health benefits. Other shoes actually make a [U]mbt sneakers[/U] legitimate difference. If you want footwear that truly helps, MBT shoes are the first [U][B]mbt walking shoes[/U][/B] step toward a healthier you.

What does MBT stand for? Good question. The [B]mbt sandals[/B] answer: Masai Barefoot Technology. They're designed to [B]mbt shoes cheap[/B] simulate walking barefoot, which helped our ancestors to walk [U]MBT[/U] healthier than we do. Modern humans cram their feet into all kinds [U][B]MBT[/U][/B] of crazy, uncomfortable shoes, and we walk on [U][B]MBT shoes[/U][/B] unnatural surfaces. MBT returns our feet to their natural, healthier [U]mbt shoes best prices[/U] environment.

MBT shoes actually trigger and enforce the [B]mbt shoes sale[/B] tiny muscles that cause our bodies to naturally absorb [U]mbt shoes review[/U] shock. The patented construction of the MBT soles features a [U][B]footwear etc[/U][/B] unique sensor that causes a simulation of being on uneven [U]mbt shoes cheap[/U] ground. It causes an instability that causes the body [B][URL=http://www.mbtplus.com/]footwear etc[/URL][/B] to react with slight movements to compensate for the instability. Thus, a "rolling" process [B]mbt sandals[/B] begins. This active, natural balancing act causes our bodies to automatically [U][B]mbt shoes best prices[/U][/B] exercise. As a result, muscles are strengthened and toned and posture is improved. Also, we experience less joint stress and back [U]discount mbt shoes[/U] pain. Clearly, it's quite a workout, and the benefits are vast.

Many top athletes credit MBT shoes for enhancing their [U][B]mbt walking shoes[/U][/B] training routines. Celebrities are also singing MBT's praises [B]MBT shoes[/B] for their alleged ability to tone, reduce cellulite and assist in weight loss. Naturally, this has caused the shoes to [U][B]mbt shoes cheap[/U][/B] get quite a bit of attention.


MBT's simple-yet-effective rolling [U][B]mbt discount shoes[/U][/B] action with each step is the strategy behind their [B]footwear etc[/B] brilliance. Not long after you begin wearing these shoes and utilizing the rolling technique, you notice [B]MBT shoes[/B] a difference. Your knees and back feel better. Neck [B]mbt shoes review[/B] and shoulder tension begin to melt away. Your joints are less stressed. Your thighs and [U][B]mbt shoes best prices[/U][/B] buttocks appear more toned. Perhaps you [U][B]mbt sneakers[/U][/B] even notice a difference in your waistline. Yes, it's the shoes. When you [U][B]mbt walking shoes[/U][/B] wear them, you actually burn more calories when simply standing than you do when [B]MBT shoes[/B] wearing standard shoes. Scientific research proves it.


Now you see why keeping a natural balance is crucial toward maintaining [B]mbt shoes review[/B] a healthier you. If you're making your health a priority, then doesn't it make [U][B]mbt shoes best prices[/U][/B] sense to choose footwear that not only increases your fitness level, but also [B]MBT shoes[/B] supports improved overall health? Now that you understand what all the [U][B]MBT[/U][/B] hype is about, perhaps it's time to try the MBT experience. Your body will thank [B]mbt sneakers[/B] you.

Anonymous said...

As y'all might have noticed, I will do whatever it takes to [B][URL=http://www.tiffanyfree.uk.com]tiffany london[/URL][/B] weed out the most popular and chic jewelry around, even it takes traveling to [U][B]tiffany sets[/U][/B] very warm, beautiful areas like the island of Siesta Key in Florida. In fact, I'm even staying an extra few days here [U]pandora beads[/U] just to make sure that I absorb as much information and style as humanly [B]tiffany engagement rings[/B] possible (either that or I'm simply not interested in journeying back to the cold tundra that is New York City). Either way, this is the best way for me to [B]pandora uk[/B] report back to you all the excellent styles that are pervading the fashion scene for the [U]tiffany][/U] spring and summer of 2009!

If any of you saw the 2008 romantic comedy, Fool's [U][B]pandora bracelets[/U][/B] Gold, I'm certain you found yourself frantically Googling Kate Hudson's Palm [B][URL=http://www.tiffanyfree.uk.com]tiffany engagement rings[/URL][/B] Tree Necklace to find out where you could get one just like it. The palm tree necklace was popular last year, and is still flying [B]pandora beads[/B] off the shelves today. There truly is something appealing about this shining sterling silver and cubic zirconia necklace with its intricate palm tree design. Of course, we're all aware that [B]tiffany bracelets[/B] the palm tree necklace that Kate wears in the movie is the real Tiffany & Co. version, which is made of diamonds, but unless you [U][B]tiffany engagement rings[/U][/B] are also a multi-millionaire like Kate, you probably will also stick to the inspired [U]tiffany bracelets][/U] version.

On top of various forms of palm tree jewelry, I have [U]pandora jewellery[/U] found a bevvy of starfish, seahorse, and turquoise and coral-colored jewelry in the many boutiques and shops that Siesta [U]tiffany pendants][/U] Key boasts. Look for two-tone starfish jewelry as a big hit this spring and summer, as well [U][B]pandora bracelets[/U][/B] as the Tiffany Inspired Anchor Necklaces, which is another fan-favorite. It also incorporates a [B]pandora jewellery[/B] sterling silver and cubic zirconia design that is nautical and airy for the [B]tiffany pendants[/B] warmer weather.

Another ring that I get numerous compliments [B][URL=http://www.pandorajewellery.uk.com]pandora uk[/URL][/B] on is an oxidized silver ring that I wear that has a big round cultured freshwater pearl at its center. The oxidized [U][B]tiffany uk[/U][/B] silver and pearl blends classiness with art-nouveau for a modern look that is truly [U][B]pandora bracelets[/U][/B] unique and sure to catch some attention.